15 Broiler Pan Substitutes! How To Broil Without A Broiler Pan?

Are you looking for a broiler pan substitute? 

Perhaps you’ve been following a recipe that calls for a broiler pan, but you don’t have one on hand. 

Don’t worry! In this article, you will learn to broil without a broiler pan and also, we will explore various alternatives to broiler pans that you can use to achieve similar results. 

Whether you’re grilling, roasting, or broiling, we’ve got you covered with practical and accessible options. Let’s dive in!

How To Broil Without A Broiler Pan?

To broil without a broiler pan, use alternatives like a wire cooling rack on a baking sheet, a cast iron skillet, or an oven-safe grill pan. These options promote even cooking, collect drippings, and offer versatile cooking surfaces. 

Select the most suitable substitute based on your recipe and enjoy broiling delicious dishes without a dedicated broiler pan.

Also Read – What Is A Broiler Pan?

Why Might You Need A Broiler Pan Substitute?

There are several reasons why you might need a substitute for a broiler pan. It could be that you don’t own a broiler pan, or perhaps you’re in a situation where you can’t access one at the moment. 

Don’t worry; several alternatives can help you achieve similar results without compromising the taste and texture of your dish.

15 Broiler Pan Substitutes

Explore 15 different alternatives to a broiler pan that can be used for cooking:

1. Wire Cooling Rack And Baking Sheet
2. Cast Iron Skillet
3. Oven-Safe Grill Pan
4. Roasting Rack And Baking Sheet
5. Foil-Lined Baking Sheet
6. Grill Grates
7. Oven-Safe Wire Rack
8. Pizza Stone
9. Aluminum Foil Packets
10. Oven Broiling Pan
11. Adjustable Roasting Rack
12. Stainless Steel Cooling Rack
13. Barbecue Grill Basket
14. Oven-Safe Skewers
15. Oven-Safe Casserole Dish

Also Read – Are Gotham Steel Pans Oven-Safe?

1. Wire Cooling Rack And Baking Sheet

A wire cooling rack placed on top of a baking sheet can be an excellent alternative to a broiler pan. This makeshift setup allows you to achieve similar results when broiling your food.

• When using a wire cooling rack and baking sheet as a substitute, the wire cooling rack plays a crucial role. 
• Its open and elevated design allows hot air to circulate freely around the food while it cooks. 
• This circulation promotes even cooking and browning, giving your dish a deliciously crispy exterior.
• The baking sheet serves as a practical companion to the wire cooling rack. 
• It is placed underneath the rack to collect any drippings or grease that may fall from the food during the cooking process. 

This setup not only prevents the drippings from causing a mess in your oven but also makes cleanup much easier afterward.

To use this substitute:

1. Simply place the wire cooling rack on top of the baking sheet. Make sure the rack is stable and evenly positioned. 
2. Arrange the food you want to broil on the wire rack, ensuring that it is spread out to allow for proper heat circulation.
3. Preheat your oven to the recommended temperature for broiling, and then place the wire cooling rack with the food on the baking sheet inside the oven. 
4. Follow your recipe’s instructions for broiling time and temperature, adjusting as needed based on the specific dish you are preparing.

Throughout the broiling process, the wire cooling rack and baking sheet combination will work together to mimic the functionality of a broiler pan. 

The wire rack allows the heat to reach all sides of the food, promoting even cooking and browning. Meanwhile, the baking sheet catches any drippings or grease, preventing them from making a mess in your oven.

• Once your food is fully cooked, carefully remove the wire cooling rack and baking sheet from the oven. 
• Be cautious as they will be hot. Transfer the food to a serving dish or let it cool slightly before enjoying your flavorful and beautifully broiled creation.

Afterward, cleaning up is a breeze. 

• Simply remove any remaining food particles from the wire cooling rack and wash them by hand or in the dishwasher. 
• The baking sheet can be easily cleaned as well, either by hand or using appropriate cleaning methods for the specific material it is made of.

So, if you find yourself without a broiler pan, don’t worry! Grab a wire cooling rack and a baking sheet, and you’ll have a reliable substitute that allows you to achieve similar broiling results. 

Enjoy the convenience, even cooking, and easy cleanup that this alternative offers.

Also Read – Are Calphalon Pans Oven-Safe?

2. Cast Iron Skillet

A cast iron skillet is a highly versatile kitchen tool that can serve as an excellent substitute for a broiler pan. Its ability to retain and distribute heat evenly makes it ideal for broiling various types of food. 

Here’s how you can use a cast iron skillet for broiling:

1. Preheating The Skillet: Start by preheating the cast iron skillet in the oven. Place it on the middle rack and set the oven temperature to the recommended broiling level. Allow the skillet to heat up for a few minutes until it becomes hot.
2. Preparing The Food: While the skillet is preheating, prepare the food you want to broil. Season it according to your preference and any recipe instructions. Make sure the food is ready to be placed directly into the hot skillet.
3. Handling The Hot Skillet: It’s essential to exercise caution when handling the hot cast iron skillet. Remember that the entire skillet, including the handle, will be extremely hot. Use oven mitts or heat-resistant gloves to protect your hands from burns.
4. Placing The Food In The Skillet:
   1. Once the skillet is preheated, carefully remove it from the oven using oven mitts or gloves. 
   2. Place the seasoned food directly into the hot skillet. 
   3. Be mindful of any sizzling or splattering that may occur when the foot makes contact with the heated surface.
5. Broiling The Food:
   1. Return the skillet with the food to the oven and position it on the middle rack or as recommended by your recipe. 
   2. Broil the food for the specified amount of time or until it reaches the desired level of doneness. 
   3. Keep an eye on the food while it’s broiling to prevent overcooking or burning.
6. Flipping Or Adjusting The Food:
   1. Depending on the recipe and the type of food you’re broiling, you may need to flip or adjust the position of the food during the cooking process. 
   2. Use tongs or a spatula to carefully turn the food or move it to ensure even cooking on all sides.
7. Monitoring The Cooking Process: While broiling in a cast iron skillet, it’s important to monitor the cooking process closely. Cast iron retains heat well, which can result in rapid cooking. Regularly check the food’s progress to avoid undercooking or overcooking.
8. Handling And Cleaning The Skillet:
   1. Once the food is broiled to perfection, carefully remove the hot skillet from the oven using oven mitts or gloves. 
   2. Place it on a heat-resistant surface and allow it to cool down before handling it again. 
   3. Remember that the skillet will retain heat for a while after being removed from the oven.

When it comes to cleaning a cast iron skillet used for broiling, avoid using harsh soaps or abrasive scrubbers, as they can strip away the skillet’s seasoned surface. 

Instead, use a brush or sponge with hot water to remove any food residue. Dry the skillet thoroughly and apply a thin layer of oil to prevent rusting.

Also Read – Why Do Pans Warp?

3. Oven-Safe Grill Pan

An oven-safe grill pan with ridges can be an excellent substitute for a broiler pan. This versatile tool allows you to achieve the effect of grilling or broiling indoors. 

Here’s how you can use an oven-safe grill pan as a substitute:

1. Preheating The Grill Pan: Start by preheating the oven-safe grill pan in the oven. Place the pan on the middle rack and set the oven temperature to the recommended broiling level. Allow the grill pan to heat up for a few minutes until it becomes hot.
2. Preparing The Food: While the grill pan is preheating, prepare the food you want to broil. Season it according to your preference and any recipe instructions. Make sure the food is ready to be placed on the ridges of the grill pan.
3. Handling The Hot Grill Pan: It’s important to handle the hot grill pan with caution. Use oven mitts or heat-resistant gloves to protect your hands from burns. Remember that the entire grill pan, including the handle, will be extremely hot.
4. Placing The Food On The Grill Pan:
   1. Once the grill pan is preheated, carefully remove it from the oven using oven mitts or gloves. 
   2. Place the seasoned food directly on the ridges of the hot grill pan. 
   3. The ridges will create grill marks on the food and allow excess fat to drain away.
5. Broiling The Food:
   1. Return the grill pan with the food to the oven and position it on the middle rack or as recommended by your recipe. 
   2. Broil the food for the specified amount of time or until it reaches the desired level of doneness. 
   3. Keep an eye on the food while it’s broiling to prevent overcooking or burning.
6. Flipping Or Adjusting The Food:
   1. Depending on the recipe and the type of food you’re broiling, you may need to flip or adjust the position of the food during the cooking process. 
   2. Use tongs or a spatula to carefully turn the food or move it to ensure even cooking on both sides.
7. Monitoring The Cooking Process:
   1. While broiling with an oven-safe grill pan, it’s important to monitor the cooking process closely. 
   2. The ridges of the grill pan create grill marks and allow excess fat to drain away, resulting in a flavorful and healthier dish. 
   3. Adjust the broiling time as needed to achieve the desired level of browning and doneness.
8. Handling And Cleaning The Grill Pan:
   1. Once the food is broiled to perfection, carefully remove the hot grill pan from the oven using oven mitts or gloves. 
   2. Place it on a heat-resistant surface and allow it to cool down before handling it again. 
   3. Remember that the grill pan will retain heat for a while after being removed from the oven.

When it comes to cleaning the oven-safe grill pan, follow the manufacturer’s instructions. 

• Most grill pans are made of materials that can withstand high temperatures and are easy to clean. 
• Use a brush or sponge with hot soapy water to remove any food residue. 
• Dry the grill pan thoroughly before storing it.

Using an oven-safe grill pan with ridges as a substitute for a broiler pan allows you to achieve deliciously grilled or broiled dishes indoors. The ridges create beautiful grill marks and help drain excess fat from the food, resulting in a flavorful and healthier meal.

Also Read – Can You Put A Roasting Pan On The Stove?

4. Roasting Rack And Baking Sheet

If you don’t have a broiler pan on hand, you can easily create a substitute using a roasting rack and a baking sheet. This makeshift setup allows for even cooking while collecting any drippings. 

Here’s how you can use a roasting rack and baking sheet as a broiler pan substitute:

1. Assembling The Setup: Begin by placing the baking sheet on a stable surface, such as a countertop or oven rack. Make sure it is large enough to accommodate the roasting rack and the food you’ll be broiling.
2. Positioning The Roasting Rack:
   1. Next, place the roasting rack on top of the baking sheet. 
   2. The roasting rack should be elevated to allow air circulation and promote even cooking. 
   3. Ensure that the rack is securely positioned on the baking sheet to prevent any accidents during the broiling process.
3. Preparing The Food: Season or marinate the food you intend to broil according to your preferences and recipe instructions. Place the food directly on the roasting rack, making sure it is evenly spread out to allow for thorough cooking.
4. Broiling The Food: Preheat your oven to the recommended broiling temperature. Once the oven is preheated, carefully place the baking sheet with the roasting rack and food on the middle rack of the oven.
5. Monitoring The Broiling Process:
   1. Keep a close eye on the food as it broils. 
   2. The roasting rack and baking sheet setup allows hot air to circulate the food, facilitating even cooking and browning. 
   3. Adjust the oven temperature and broiling time as needed based on the specific dish you are preparing.
6. Handling And Cleaning:
   1. After the food has been broiled to your desired level of doneness, remove the baking sheet with the roasting rack from the oven. 
   2. Be cautious as both the baking sheet and roasting rack will be hot. 
   3. Use oven mitts or heat-resistant gloves to handle them safely.
7. Serving And Cleanup:
   1. Transfer the broiled food from the roasting rack to a serving dish or allow it to cool slightly before enjoying it. 
   2. The baking sheet will have caught any drippings or excess fat, making cleanup easier. 
   3. Dispose of any collected drippings and clean the baking sheet according to its specific cleaning instructions.

Using a roasting rack and baking sheet as a broiler pan substitute provides a practical solution for achieving even cooking and collecting drippings. This setup allows hot air to circulate the food, promoting consistent browning and flavor development.

Also Read – How Many Mini Loaf Pans Equal A Regular Loaf Pan?

5. Foil-Lined Baking Sheet

When you find yourself without a broiler pan, a foil-lined baking sheet can come to the rescue as a viable alternative. With just a few simple steps, you can create a makeshift broiler pan substitute using readily available materials. 

Here’s how to use a foil-lined baking sheet:

1. Preparing The Baking Sheet:
   1. Start by selecting a baking sheet that is large enough to accommodate the food you’ll be broiling. 
   2. Line the baking sheet with aluminum foil, making sure it covers the entire surface. 
   3. The foil should have raised edges to capture any drippings that occur during the broiling process.
2. Shaping The Foil: Smooth out the foil to eliminate any wrinkles or creases. Take care to create a flat and even surface to ensure proper cooking and to prevent the food from sticking to the foil.
3. Preparing The Food: Season or marinate the food you wish to broil according to your preferences and recipe instructions. Place the seasoned food directly on the foil-lined baking sheet, arranging it in a single layer for even cooking.
4. Broiling The Food: Preheat your oven to the recommended broiling temperature. Once the oven is preheated, carefully place the foil-lined baking sheet with the food on the middle rack of the oven.
5. Monitoring The Broiling Process: Keep a close eye on the food as it broils. The foil-lined baking sheet will help conduct heat and promote even cooking. Adjust the oven temperature and broiling time as needed based on the specific dish you are preparing.
6. Handling And Cleaning:
   1. Once the food is broiled to perfection, remove the baking sheet from the oven using oven mitts or heat-resistant gloves. 
   2. Take caution as both the baking sheet and the foil may be hot. 
   3. Allow the food to cool slightly before transferring it to a serving dish.
7. Cleanup: One of the advantages of using a foil-lined baking sheet is the easy cleanup it offers. After the broiling process, carefully remove the foil from the baking sheet, along with any collected drippings. Discard the foil and wash the baking sheet as usual.

Using a foil-lined baking sheet as a broiler pan substitute provides a quick and convenient solution. The foil acts as a barrier between the food and the baking sheet, preventing sticking and facilitating cleanup. 

Keep in mind that the foil may affect the cooking process slightly, as it can reflect heat. Therefore, it’s important to monitor the broiling progress closely and make any necessary adjustments.

Also Read – Springform Pan Substitutes

6. Grill Grates

When you find yourself without a broiler pan, a foil-lined baking sheet can come to the rescue as a viable alternative. With just a few simple steps, you can create a makeshift broiler pan substitute using readily available materials. 

Here’s how to use a foil-lined baking sheet:

1. Preparing The Baking Sheet:
   1. Start by selecting a baking sheet that is large enough to accommodate the food you’ll be broiling. 
   2. Line the baking sheet with aluminum foil, making sure it covers the entire surface. 
   3. The foil should have raised edges to capture any drippings that occur during the broiling process.
2. Shaping The Foil: Smooth out the foil to eliminate any wrinkles or creases. Take care to create a flat and even surface to ensure proper cooking and to prevent the food from sticking to the foil.
3. Preparing The Food: Season or marinate the food you wish to broil according to your preferences and recipe instructions. Place the seasoned food directly on the foil-lined baking sheet, arranging it in a single layer for even cooking.
4. Broiling The Food: Preheat your oven to the recommended broiling temperature. Once the oven is preheated, carefully place the foil-lined baking sheet with the food on the middle rack of the oven.
5. Monitoring The Broiling Process: Keep a close eye on the food as it broils. The foil-lined baking sheet will help conduct heat and promote even cooking. Adjust the oven temperature and broiling time as needed based on the specific dish you are preparing.
6. Handling And Cleaning:
   1. Once the food is broiled to perfection, remove the baking sheet from the oven using oven mitts or heat-resistant gloves. 
   2. Take caution as both the baking sheet and the foil may be hot. 
   3. Allow the food to cool slightly before transferring it to a serving dish.
7. Cleanup: One of the advantages of using a foil-lined baking sheet is the easy cleanup it offers. After the broiling process, carefully remove the foil from the baking sheet, along with any collected drippings. Discard the foil and wash the baking sheet as usual.

Using a foil-lined baking sheet as a broiler pan substitute provides a quick and convenient solution. The foil acts as a barrier between the food and the baking sheet, preventing sticking and facilitating cleanup. 

Keep in mind that the foil may affect the cooking process slightly, as it can reflect heat. Therefore, it’s important to monitor the broiling progress closely and make any necessary adjustments.

Also Read – Tart Pan Substitutes

7. Oven-Safe Wire Rack

If you have an oven-safe wire rack, typically used for cooling baked goods, it can serve as an effective substitute for a broiler pan. By pairing the wire rack with a baking sheet, you can achieve even cooking and easy cleanup. 

Here’s how to utilize an oven-safe wire rack as a broiler pan alternative:

1. Preparing The Baking Sheet: Start by selecting a baking sheet that is large enough to accommodate the wire rack and the food you’ll be broiling. Place the baking sheet on a stable surface, such as a countertop or oven rack.
2. Positioning The Oven-Safe Wire Rack:
   1. Next, place the oven-safe wire rack on top of the baking sheet. 
   2. Ensure that the wire rack is stable and elevated to allow proper air circulation around the food. 
   3. This setup promotes even cooking and helps prevent the food from sitting in its juices.
3. Preparing The Food: Season or marinate the food according to your preferences and recipe instructions. Place the seasoned food directly on the wire rack, ensuring it is evenly spread out for consistent cooking.
4. Broiling The Food: Preheat your oven to the recommended broiling temperature. Once the oven is preheated, carefully place the baking sheet with the wire rack and food on the middle rack of the oven.
5. Monitoring The Broiling Process:
   1. Keep a close eye on the food as it broils. 
   2. The oven-safe wire rack allows hot air to circulate the food, promoting even browning and cooking.
   3. Adjust the oven temperature and broiling time as needed based on the specific dish you are preparing.
6. Handling And Cleanup:
   1. After the food has been broiled to your desired level of doneness, remove the baking sheet with the wire rack from the oven. 
   2. Exercise caution, as both the baking sheet and wire rack will be hot. 
   3. Use oven mitts or heat-resistant gloves to handle them safely.
7. Serving And Cleanup:
   1. Transfer the broiled food from the wire rack to a serving dish or allow it to cool slightly before enjoying it. 
   2. The baking sheet underneath the wire rack collects any drippings or grease, making cleanup a breeze. 
   3. Dispose of any collected drippings and clean the baking sheet according to its specific cleaning instructions.

By using an oven-safe wire rack in combination with a baking sheet, you can achieve excellent broiling results. The wire rack allows for proper air circulation around the food, resulting in even cooking and browning. Meanwhile, the baking sheet collects any drippings, making cleanup quick and easy.

Also Read – Can You Bake A Cake In A Springform Pan?

8. Pizza Stone

In addition to its main purpose of baking pizzas, a pizza stone can be utilized as a practical substitute for a broiler pan. By preheating the pizza stone in the oven and placing the food directly on it, you can achieve crispy and evenly cooked dishes. 

Here’s how you can use a pizza stone as a broiler pan alternative:

1. Preheating The Pizza Stone: Begin by placing the pizza stone in the oven and preheating it to the recommended broiling temperature. It’s essential to preheat the stone adequately to ensure even heat distribution and optimal cooking results.
2. Preparing The Food: While the pizza stone is preheating, prepare the food you wish to broil. Season or marinate the food according to your preferences and recipe instructions. Ensure that the food is ready to be placed directly on the hot pizza stone.
3. Handling The Hot Pizza Stone: Once the oven and the pizza stone have reached the desired broiling temperature, carefully remove the hot stone using oven mitts or heat-resistant gloves. Take precautions to avoid burns as the stone will be extremely hot.
4. Placing The Food On The Pizza Stone: 
   1. Immediately place the seasoned food directly onto the hot pizza stone. 
   2. The porous nature of the stone allows it to absorb and distribute heat evenly, resulting in crispy and evenly cooked dishes. 
   3. Arrange the food on the stone, ensuring that it is evenly spaced for uniform cooking.
5. Broiling The Food:
   1. Return the pizza stone with the food to the oven and position it on the middle rack or as specified by your recipe. 
   2. Broil the food for the recommended duration or until it reaches your desired level of doneness. 
   3. Keep a close eye on the cooking process to prevent overcooking or burning.
6. Monitoring The Cooking Process:
   1. While broiling on a pizza stone, closely monitor the cooking progress to achieve the desired results. 
   2. The pizza stone’s ability to absorb and evenly distribute heat promotes even browning and crispiness. 
   3. Adjust the broiling time and temperature as necessary, depending on the specific dish you are preparing.
7. Handling And Cleanup:
   1. Once the food is broiled to perfection, use oven mitts or gloves to remove the hot pizza stone from the oven. 
   2. Place it on a heat-resistant surface and allow it to cool before handling it again. 
   3. Remember that the pizza stone will retain heat for a significant period.

When it comes to cleaning the pizza stone, avoid using soap or detergent, as it can be absorbed by the porous material. Instead, allow the stone to cool completely and gently scrape off any food residue using a spatula or a brush. If necessary, wipe it with a damp cloth and let it air dry thoroughly before storing.

Also Read – Is Pan Frying Healthy?

9. Aluminum Foil Packets

When it comes to broiling certain foods like fish or vegetables, creating individual aluminum foil packets can be a fantastic alternative. 

By tightly wrapping the food in aluminum foil and ensuring a secure seal, you can create a cooking environment that gently cooks the food while retaining its moisture. 

Here’s how you can use aluminum foil packets as a broiler pan substitute:

1. Preparing The Aluminum Foil: Tear off a sheet of aluminum foil large enough to fully enclose the food. The size of the foil will depend on the portion and shape of the food you are broiling.
2. Placing The Food On The Foil: Place the food, such as fish fillets or a selection of vegetables, onto the center of the aluminum foil. Season or add any desired herbs, spices, or marinades to enhance the flavor.
3. Wrapping The Foil Packet:
   1. Bring the two long sides of the foil together above the food and fold them over each other to create a tight seal. 
   2. Fold and crimp the remaining edges of the foil to completely enclose the food within the packet. 
   3. Ensure that the seal is secure to prevent any steam or juices from escaping.
4. Preparing For Broiling: Preheat your oven to the recommended broiling temperature. Place the aluminum foil packets directly on the oven rack or a baking sheet, depending on your preference and the size of the packets.
5. Broiling The Foil Packets:
   1. Carefully position the baking sheet or oven rack with the foil packets on the middle rack of the oven. 
   2. Broil the packets for the recommended time or until the food reaches the desired level of doneness. 
   3. The foil packets trap the steam and juices, creating a gentle cooking environment.
6. Monitoring The Cooking Process:
   1. Keep a close eye on the foil packets as they broil to prevent overcooking. 
   2. The sealed foil packets help retain moisture and ensure that the food cooks gently. 
   3. Adjust the broiling time as necessary based on the specific ingredients and your desired results.
7. Handling And Serving:
   1. Once the foil packets have finished broiling, carefully remove them from the oven using oven mitts or heat-resistant gloves. 
   2. Allow the packets to cool for a few minutes before opening them to release the steam.
   3.  Exercise caution, as the steam can be hot.
8. Enjoying The Dish: Carefully open the foil packets, being mindful of the hot steam. Transfer the broiled food from the packets to serving plates or enjoy them directly from the foil for a convenient and mess-free meal.

The use of aluminum foil packets as a broiler pan substitute offers the advantage of gentle and flavorful cooking, as the steam and juices are trapped within the packet. This method is particularly suitable for delicate foods like fish or vegetables that benefit from gentle and moist cooking. 

Experiment with different ingredients and seasonings to create delicious foil packet meals that are tailored to your taste.

Please note that while aluminum foil packets can be used for broiling, they should not be placed directly on the broiler element or exposed to direct flames. 

Always ensure that the packets are positioned on a baking sheet or oven rack to prevent any accidents or damage to the oven.

Also Read – How To Get Burnt Sugar Off A Pan?

10. Oven Broiling Pan

When it comes to broiling, an oven-broiling pan can serve as an excellent substitute for a traditional broiler pan. Designed specifically for high-heat cooking, an oven-broiling pan typically consists of a slotted top tray and a bottom drip tray. 

If you require a broiler pan alternative, consider obtaining an oven-broiling pan from your local kitchenware store or online retailer. 

Here’s why an oven-broiling pan can be a suitable choice:

1. High-Heat Cooking:
   1. An oven-broiling pan is specifically designed to withstand high temperatures, making it ideal for broiling. 
   2. The materials used in its construction, such as stainless steel or heavy-duty aluminum, can endure the intense heat of the broiler without warping or discoloration.
2. Slotted Top Tray: The slotted top tray of an oven-broiling pan is designed to allow excess fats, oils, and juices to drain away from the food being cooked. This helps prevent the food from sitting in its drippings and promotes better browning and crispiness.
3. Bottom Drip Tray: The bottom drip tray serves the purpose of collecting the drippings that fall from the slotted top tray. This makes cleanup much easier, as you can simply remove and discard the drip tray or clean it separately.
4. Easy Availability:
   1. Oven broiling pans can typically be found in kitchenware stores or online retailers. 
   2. They come in various sizes to accommodate different oven sizes and cooking needs. 
   3. Consider checking your local stores or reputable online platforms to find an oven-broiling pan that suits your requirements.
5. Proper Air Circulation: The slotted top tray of an oven-broiling pan allows for proper air circulation around the food being cooked. This helps ensure even cooking and browning, resulting in deliciously broiled dishes.
6. Versatility: 
   1. In addition to broiling, an oven-broiling pan can also be used for other cooking methods, such as baking or roasting. 
   2. Its sturdy construction and heat-resistant properties make it a versatile kitchen tool that can be utilized for various culinary tasks.

When using an oven-broiling pan, it’s important to follow the manufacturer’s instructions and any specific guidelines provided with the pan. This ensures that you achieve the best possible results and maintain the longevity of the pan.

Also Read – How To Clean Burnt Calphalon Pans?

11. Adjustable Roasting Rack

An adjustable roasting rack is a versatile kitchen tool that can serve as a practical substitute for a broiler pan. Designed to elevate food while cooking, it allows heat to circulate evenly around the food, resulting in even browning and cooking. 

Here’s how you can use an adjustable roasting rack as a broiler pan alternative:

1. Choose The Right Size: Ensure that the adjustable roasting rack suits your baking sheet or shallow roasting pan. The rack should be adjustable in width and length to fit securely inside the cooking vessel you intend to use.
2. Preparing The Baking Sheet Or Roasting Pan: Select a baking sheet or shallow roasting pan that can accommodate the adjustable roasting rack. This will provide a stable base for the rack and catch any drippings during broiling.
3. Adjusting The Rack: Set the adjustable roasting rack to the desired width and length that fits inside the baking sheet or roasting pan. Make sure it sits securely and evenly on the chosen vessel.
4. Preheating The Oven: Preheat your oven to the recommended broiling temperature. It’s important to allow the oven to reach the desired temperature before placing the food on the adjustable roasting rack.
5. Preparing The Food: Season or marinate the food you wish to broil according to your preferences and recipe instructions. Place the prepared food on the adjustable roasting rack, ensuring it is evenly spaced for optimal heat circulation.
6. Broiling The Food:
   1. Position the baking sheet or roasting pan with the adjustable roasting rack and food on the middle rack of the preheated oven. 
   2. Broil the food for the recommended time or until it reaches your desired level of doneness. 
   3. The elevated position of the food on the rack allows the heat to circulate evenly, resulting in even cooking and browning.
7. Monitoring The Cooking Process: Keep a close eye on the food as it broils to prevent overcooking or burning. Adjust the broiling time as necessary based on the specific dish you are preparing and the desired results.
8. Handling And Cleanup:
   1. Once the food is broiled to perfection, use oven mitts or heat-resistant gloves to remove the baking sheet or roasting pan from the oven. 
   2. Allow the food and the adjustable roasting rack to cool before handling. 
   3. Cleaning the rack is usually straightforward, as it can be washed by hand or in the dishwasher, depending on the manufacturer’s instructions.

An adjustable roasting rack offers the advantage of elevating the food, allowing heat to circulate evenly during the broiling process. This results in beautifully browned and evenly cooked dishes. 

Its versatility makes it a valuable tool in the kitchen beyond broiling, as it can be used for roasting, baking, or even cooling baked goods.

Ensure that you select an adjustable roasting rack of the appropriate size and quality to ensure stability and durability.

Also Read – How Many Quarts In An 8×8 Pan?

12. Stainless Steel Cooling Rack

A stainless steel cooling rack can be a fantastic alternative for broiling when you don’t have a traditional broiler pan. With its sturdy construction and heat-resistant properties, a stainless steel cooling rack provides a stable platform for broiling your favorite dishes. 

Here’s how you can use a stainless steel cooling rack as a broiler pan substitute:

1. Select The Right Size: Choose a stainless steel cooling rack that fits comfortably on top of a baking sheet. Ensure that the rack is stable and secure when placed on the baking sheet.
2. Preparing The Baking Sheet: Select a baking sheet that accommodates the size of the cooling rack. The baking sheet will catch any drippings and provide support for the rack during the broiling process.
3. Positioning The Cooling Rack: Place the stainless steel cooling rack on top of the baking sheet, ensuring it is elevated. The elevated position allows air to circulate the food and promotes even cooking and browning.
4. Preheating The Oven: Preheat your oven to the recommended broiling temperature. It’s crucial to let the oven reach the desired temperature before placing the food on the stainless steel cooling rack.
5. Preparing The Food: Season or marinate your food according to your preferences and the recipe instructions. Place the prepared food on top of the stainless steel cooling rack, arranging it evenly for optimal broiling.
6. Broiling The Food:
   1. Position the baking sheet with the stainless steel cooling rack and food on the middle rack of the preheated oven. 
   2. Broil the food for the recommended time or until it reaches the desired level of doneness. 
   3. The elevated position of the food on the cooling rack allows heat to circulate evenly, resulting in deliciously broiled dishes.
7. Monitoring The Cooking Process: Keep a close eye on the food as it broils to avoid overcooking or burning. Adjust the broiling time as needed based on the specific dish and desired results.
8. Handling And Cleanup:
   1. Once the food is broiled to perfection, use oven mitts or heat-resistant gloves to remove the baking sheet with the stainless steel cooling rack from the oven. 
   2. Allow the food and the rack to cool before handling. 
   3. Cleaning the cooling rack is usually a breeze, as stainless steel is dishwasher safe. Alternatively, you can hand wash it with warm, soapy water.

The stainless steel construction of the cooling rack ensures durability and resistance to high temperatures. It allows air to circulate the food, resulting in even cooking and browning. 

Moreover, the elevated position of the food helps to prevent excessive moisture buildup and ensures a crispy texture.

A stainless steel cooling rack is a versatile kitchen tool beyond broiling. It can also be used for cooling baked goods, drying dishes, or even as a roasting rack. Its easy-to-clean nature makes it a convenient choice for any cooking enthusiast.

Also Read – How Many Quarts In A 9×13 Pan?

13. Barbecue Grill Basket

A barbecue grill basket can serve as a versatile substitute for a broiler pan, particularly when grilling delicate items such as fish or small vegetables. 

With its small holes, the grill basket securely holds the food while allowing heat to reach it from all sides, resulting in even cooking and delicious flavors. 

Here’s how you can use a barbecue grill basket as a broiler pan alternative:

1. Select The Right Grill Basket: Choose a barbecue grill basket with small holes that is suitable for the type of food you plan to broil. Ensure that the basket is large enough to hold the food securely while still allowing heat to circulate.
2. Preheat The Grill: Preheat your grill to the desired broiling temperature. It’s important to give the grill enough time to reach the proper heat before placing the food in the basket.
3. Preparing The Food: Season or marinate your food as desired. Place the food in the barbecue grill basket, ensuring that it is evenly distributed and doesn’t overcrowd the basket. This allows the heat to circulate and cook the food uniformly.
4. Positioning The Grill Basket: Place the barbecue grill basket on the preheated grill grates, ensuring it is secure and won’t tip over. Close the grill lid to trap the heat and promote even cooking.
5. Monitoring The Cooking Process: Keep a close eye on the food as it cooks in the grill basket. Adjust the grilling time as needed, based on the specific food and desired level of doneness.
6. Flipping The Food: Depending on the recipe and the food being cooked, you may need to flip the food in the grill basket halfway through the cooking process. This ensures even browning and thorough cooking on both sides.
7. Removing The Food: Once the food is cooked to your desired level, use heat-resistant gloves or tongs to carefully remove the barbecue grill basket from the grill. Place it on a heat-resistant surface to cool.
8. Serving And Enjoying: Transfer the cooked food from the grill basket to a serving platter or individual plates. The grill basket’s small holes prevent food from falling through, ensuring that you can savor every flavorful bite.
9. Cleaning The Grill Basket: After the grill basket has cooled, clean it thoroughly with warm, soapy water or follow the manufacturer’s instructions. Some grill baskets are dishwasher-safe for added convenience.

A barbecue grill basket offers a practical and efficient way to broil delicate foods on the grill. Its design allows heat to reach the food from all sides, resulting in even cooking and the characteristic smoky flavors associated with grilling. 

The small holes prevent small food items from falling through the grill grates while still allowing the flames and heat to impart delicious grill marks and flavors.

Also Read – How Many Quarts Are In A 9×9 Pan?

14. Oven-Safe Skewers

Oven-safe skewers can be an excellent alternative to a broiler pan, especially when broiling kebabs or skewered foods. These skewers are designed to withstand high oven temperatures, allowing you to achieve deliciously broiled results. 

Here’s how you can use oven-safe skewers as a substitute for a broiler pan:

1. Preparing The Skewers: Soak the oven-safe skewers in water for about 30 minutes before use. This prevents them from burning or charring during the broiling process.
2. Preparing The Ingredients:
   1. Prepare your kebabs or skewered foods by threading the ingredients onto the skewers. 
   2. You can alternate between meats, vegetables, and other desired components. 
   3. Ensure that the ingredients are evenly distributed on the skewers for uniform cooking.
3. Preheating The Oven: Preheat your oven to the recommended broiling temperature. It’s essential to allow the oven to reach the desired heat before placing the skewers inside.
4. Positioning The Skewers: Place the prepared skewers on a baking sheet lined with aluminum foil or parchment paper. The elevated position of the skewers on the baking sheet ensures even cooking and allows any drippings to be caught by the sheet for easy cleanup.
5. Broiling The Skewers: 
   1. Position the baking sheet with the skewers on the middle rack of the preheated oven. 
   2. Broil the skewers for the recommended time, or until the ingredients are cooked to your desired level. 
   3. Keep a close eye on the skewers to prevent them from overcooking or burning.
6. Flipping The Skewers: Depending on the recipe and cooking time, you may need to flip the skewers halfway through the broiling process. This ensures that all sides of the ingredients are evenly cooked and browned.
7. Monitoring The Cooking Process: Pay attention to the skewers as they broil in the oven. Adjust the broiling time as needed based on the specific ingredients and desired level of doneness.
8. Handling And Serving:
   1. Once the skewers are cooked to perfection, use oven mitts or heat-resistant gloves to carefully remove the baking sheet from the oven. 
   2. Allow the skewers to cool slightly before handling. 
   3. Transfer them to a serving platter or individual plates, and enjoy the flavorful broiled kebabs or skewered foods.
9. Cleaning Up: Once the skewers have cooled completely, discard any remaining skewers that may have charred during the broiling process. Clean the baking sheet as needed, either by handwashing or using a dishwasher if it is dishwasher-safe.

Oven-safe skewers offer a convenient and efficient way to broil kebabs or skewered foods without the need for a traditional broiler pan. Their ability to withstand high oven temperatures allows for even cooking and delicious charred flavors. 

Additionally, the elevated position on the baking sheet ensures that any drippings are caught, making cleanup a breeze.

Also Read – Why Do Cast Iron Pans Crack?

15. Oven-Safe Casserole Dish

When you don’t have a broiler pan on hand, an oven-safe casserole dish can step in as a practical substitute. With its raised edges and heat-resistant construction, a casserole dish can effectively serve as a makeshift broiler pan. 

Here’s how you can use an oven-safe casserole dish as a substitute:

1. Selecting The Right Casserole Dish: Choose an oven-safe casserole dish that is appropriate for broiling. Look for a dish with sturdy construction and materials that can withstand high oven temperatures.
2. Preheating The Oven: Preheat your oven to the desired broiling temperature. It’s crucial to allow the oven to reach the proper heat before placing the casserole dish inside.
3. Preparing The Food: Place the food you wish to broil into the casserole dish, making sure it is evenly distributed and not overcrowded. This allows the heat to circulate the food and promotes even cooking.
4. Positioning The Casserole Dish: Place the filled casserole dish on the middle rack of the preheated oven. Ensure that the dish is centered and properly positioned to receive direct heat from the broiler element.
5. Broiling The Food: Follow the broiling instructions in your recipe. Keep a close eye on the food as it broils, adjusting the broiling time as needed. The raised edges of the casserole dish help contain any drippings and prevent them from spilling over.
6. Flipping Or Turning The Food: Depending on the recipe and desired results, you may need to flip or turn the food in the casserole dish halfway through the broiling process. This ensures even browning and cooking on both sides.
7. Monitoring The Cooking Process: Monitor the food closely as it broils to prevent overcooking or burning. Adjust the broiling time or rack position if necessary to achieve the desired level of doneness.
8. Handling And Serving:
   1. Once the food is broiled to perfection, carefully remove the casserole dish from the oven using oven mitts or heat-resistant gloves. 
   2. Place it on a heat-resistant surface to cool slightly. 
   3. Transfer the broiled food to a serving dish or individual plates and serve promptly.
9. Cleaning Up: After the casserole dish has cooled completely, clean it using warm, soapy water or follow the manufacturer’s instructions. Some oven-safe casserole dishes are dishwasher-safe, which makes cleanup even more convenient.

An oven-safe casserole dish can serve as a reliable substitute for a broiler pan, allowing you to achieve similar broiling results. Its raised edges help contain any drippings, preventing messes and simplifying cleanup. 

With the right casserole dish, you can broil a variety of dishes with ease, from meats and poultry to vegetables and gratins.

Also Read – Can You Put Non-Stick Pans In The Dishwasher?

Final Verdict

So, when you find yourself in need of a broiler pan substitute, there are several practical options available. Each alternative offers its unique benefits and can be used based on the specific requirements of your recipe.

From wire cooling racks and baking sheets to cast iron skillets and grill pans, the options are versatile and accessible. 

Each of these alternatives offers a workaround for broiling when a dedicated broiler pan is unavailable. Consider the specific requirements of your recipe, the type of food you are broiling, and the available equipment in your kitchen to determine the best substitute for your needs.

Remember to follow the recommended cooking times and temperatures for each method to achieve optimal results. Practice caution when handling hot pans and use appropriate oven mitts or heat-resistant gloves.

So, whether you opt for a wire cooling rack and baking sheet, a cast iron skillet, an oven-safe grill pan, or any of the other options discussed, you can successfully broil a wide range of dishes without a dedicated broiler pan. 

Get creative, experiment with different alternatives, and enjoy the delicious results!

Also Read – is it safe to cook in a rusty cast iron pan?

FAQs